Many years ago, when the forests were deeper and the rivers still remembered the first rains of the world, there lived a fairy named Annabelle.
She was small and bright, like a drop of morning sunshine, and her wings shone with the pale colours of dawn. She was a curious fairy and liked to ask questions. Why the owls hunted only at night. Why the mushrooms grew in circles. Why the roots of the oldest trees stretched so far beneath the soil that they touched streams and stones that no living creature had seen.
Many creatures enjoyed these conversations. A sparrow might learn something from a beetle. A fox might learn something from a crow.
Annabelle liked to say the forest was a conversation that had begun long before any creature alive had joined it.
Most thought her harmless. A few thought her a bit odd, but not troublesome. Just different.
But one year a dry season came such as the forest had not known in living memory. The streams shrank to a trickle. Moss turned brittle, ferns withered. Saplings reached towards the sky as if searching for forgotten rain.
The elves gathered then beneath a pavilion of woven branches and spoke of what must be done.
"The old offerings have been neglected", said the eldest, "we must restore the ancient rites so the Great Oak will bless the forest again."
Word went out across the woods that every creature must bring tribute.
The deer brought sweet grasses.
The birds dropped bright feathers.
The bees gave honey.
Even the badgers dug rare roots from the dark soil.
All of it was brought to the sacred grove where the elves alone were permitted to stand before the Great Oak.
Annabelle watched this with quiet curiosity.
When the day came for the offerings, she stepped forward carrying only a small cup of clear water drawn from a hidden spring upon the hillside.
The elves frowned when they saw it.
"Is that all?", one asked.
Annabelle nodded and poured the water gently among the roots of the great tree.
"The forest does not need gifts", she said softly, "it needs care."
The elves murmured amongst themselves.
"What nonsense", said another, "these rites have preserved the forest for centuries."
Annabelle looked around the grove.
"You carry honey from the bees", she said, "and yet the flowers they depend on are trampled by the crowds that gather here. You bring grasses from the deer, even though the streams they drink from are fading. You bring roots from the badgers, though the soil grows thin where they dig."
She placed her hand against the bark of the Great Oak.
"The Great Oak does not wish for tribute", she said, "it wishes for a forest that lives."
Some who heard her began to think quietly to themselves.
But the elves did not like these words at all. For if the fairy spoke the truth, then the offerings meant little. And if the offerings meant little, the careful order the elves had built around them may begin to loosen.
Soon creatures throughout the forest were repeating Annabelle's saying: "The Great Oak hears every voice."
They said it in burrows and nests, beneath stones and in hollow logs. Even the youngest rabbits began to repeat it.
At last the elf council decided the matter could no longer be ignored.
They summoned Annabelle to answer for her words.
The trial was held in a clearing of pale birch trees whose white trunks bore the carved marks of ancient laws and judgements. The trunks there were white as old bone, and their leaves whispered even when the air was still. The elves liked the place because the ground was smooth and open. They gathered in a wide circle, with the council standing together at the centre, other animals watching from the edge of the clearing.
Annabelle arrived alone, drifting down from the branches as lightly as a falling leaf.
The eldest elf stepped forward, leaning on a staff cut from an ancient tree.
"Annabelle the wanderer", he said, "you have spoken strange things in the forest."
Annabelle tilted her head politely. "I have spoken with those who wished to talk", she replied.
"You tell the creatures that the Great Oak listens to every voice."
"That is what the roots say, can you not hear this?", Annabelle answered.
A murmur moved through the clearing.
The eldest elf tapped his staff to the ground. "You encourage disorder", he said, "If every creature believes its voice carries equal weight, the old laws weaken."
Annabelle looked around at the gathered crowd. A squirrel watched from a branch. A beetle crept along a birch branch.
"The forest already has many voices", she said calmly, "the laws did not give them their voices."
A younger elf spoke sharply: "The forest needs guardians. Without order there would be chaos."
Annabelle walked quietly to the edge of the clearing and placed her hand against the trunk of a birch tree.
"Does this tree grow because you guard it?" she asked.
The elf frowned. "It grows because the forest is properly tended."
"And who tends the roots?" Annabelle asked.
No one answered.
The council withdrew among themselves and spoke quietly for a long time. At last they returned.
"Your words loosen the basis of order", said the eldest, "if they continue, the harmony of the forest may break."
Annabelle turned back to the circle of council members.
"I did not come to argue with you" she said. "I only said that the Great Oak hears the whole forest. That is all."
"But the creatures repeat your words", said the eldest elf, "they question the old ways."
Annabelle thought for a moment, then calmly replied "Questions are how the forest learns."
This answer troubled the council more than anger would have. The eldest elf tightened his grip on the staff, his face starting to turn red.
"You are defying the rightful order of the forest."
Annabelle looked up through the pale leaves overhead.
"The forest has never been silent", she said, "that is why it lives."
"You will cease speaking these things!", the elf told her forcefully.
Annabelle thought for a moment.
Then she smiled kindly. "I do not think that I can."
That answer ended the trial. For the elves believed that if a voice could not be persuaded to fall silent, then it must be made silent.
So the council pronounced their judgement:
She would be taken to the hill where two tall trees grew close together.
There, they said, the forest itself would hold her still.
Annabelle listened without anger.
When they finished speaking, she asked only one small question.
"Have you asked the trees whether they agree?"
None of the council answered.
Annabelle was brought to the hill and lifted between the two trees. Her wings were stretched wide across the trunks, and nails were driven through the tips of her wings and into the living bark.
Creatures gathered quietly in the grass and shadows to watch. Some elves looked away, for they did not like the sound the nails made against the trees.
Annabelle hung there through the long hours while the wind moved gently through the leaves.
"You could have lived freely", a young elf guarding the trees whispered to her, "if you had kept silent."
Annabelle's wings trembled where they were fastened to the bark.
"If truth is buried", she said gently, "the forest grows crooked."
As evening came she lifted her gaze toward the deeper woods.
"Great Oak", she whispered, "forgive them. They believe they guard the forest."
Then her voice faded into the wind.
For a moment the woodland seemed to hold its breath.
Then a great stirring moved through the trees. Wind rushed across the hill, bending branches and shaking loose a flurry of leaves. The trunks groaned deeply, and with a loud crack one of the nails tore loose from the bark.
Then the other.
Annabelle's small body fell gently to the earth among the fallen leaves. As she fell, the watching elves stepped back in fear.
When the wind passed, the fairy was gone.
Some said the Great Oak had lifted her. Others said the trees themselves had refused to keep her. In time a few travellers even claimed to see a small figure walking the forest paths again, her wings torn but slowly mending.
But as years passed the forest changed.
The elves withdrew deeper into the woods. Kingdoms came, argued loudly about things, and went. Roads replaced old paths.
And still the story remained. The two trees that once stood had long since fallen. In their place grew a pair of great trunks twisted together, their branches leaning toward one another as though they still remembered something from long ago.
Travellers sometimes stopped on the hill and asked the villagers why the trees grew that way. Not because it was grand, but because it was curious.
"Ah", one of the village elders would say, settling themselves on a stone for the telling of a story, "that is where Annabelle was nailed to the trees."
Then they would tell the story from the beginning, about how a fairy spoke kindly to all the creatures of the forest. She told them the Great Oak listened to every living thing alike. But the proud elves of the old days did not like this idea. So they nailed the fairy's wings to two trees on the hill to silence her. Yet the trees themselves would not keep her.
"That is why", the villager would conclude, "the trees here grow in pairs. They remember."
People hearing the tale often reacted in different ways.
Some nodded thoughtfully and continued along the road. A few stayed quietly beneath the branches for a while.
Others missed the point entirely. There were travellers who arrived with notebooks and measuring tapes, arguing about what kind of trees must have stood there long ago. Some debated the metal of the nails. The shape of fairy wings, despite nobody having seen a fairy in centuries.
One man even tried digging among the roots in hopes of finding proof.
The villagers made him fill in the hole again.
Sometimes visitors would argue loudly about who had been right and who had been wrong in the story. The elves were villains, the fairy was a troublemaker, the rabbits should have stepped up and done something. The nails were faulty. Theories and excuses flowed like raindrops.
The old storytellers would listen politely. They had heard it all before. Many times.
Then finally the storyteller might be inclined to say, "Yes, yes. That is all very interesting. But the story was never about the elves."
This puzzled the visitors.
"If it is not about the elves", they asked, "then what is it about?"
The storyteller would look up at the branches swaying overhead for a long moment.
Sometimes they would answer.
Sometimes they would not.
And sometimes they would simply say, very gently: "The story is what remains after you have finished saying it."
Then they would stand, brush the dust from their coat, and walk down the road to continue with their lives.
Those who hurried after them rarely understood.
But those who stayed a little longer beneath the twin trees sometimes found themselves listening to the quiet creaking of the branches in the wind, and wondering why the sound felt almost like an answer.
Your comments:
Please note that while I check this page every so often, I am not able to control what users write; therefore I disclaim all liability for unpleasant and/or infringing and/or defamatory material. Undesired content will be removed as soon as it is noticed. By leaving a comment, you agree not to post material that is illegal or in bad taste, and you should be aware that the time and your IP address are both recorded, should it be necessary to find out who you are. Oh, and don't bother trying to inline HTML. I'm not that stupid! ☺ As of February 2025, commenting is no longer available to UK residents, following the implementation of the vague and overly broad Online Safety Act. You must tick the box below to verify that you are not a UK resident, and you expressly agree if you are in fact a UK resident that you will indemnify me (Richard Murray), as well as the person maintaining my site (Rob O'Donnell), the hosting providers, and so on. It's a shitty law, complain to your MP. It's not that I don't want to hear from my British friends, it's because your country makes stupid laws.
You can now follow comment additions with the comment RSS feed. This is distinct from the b.log RSS feed, so you can subscribe to one or both as you wish.
This web page is licenced for your personal, private, non-commercial use only. No automated processing by advertising systems is permitted.
RIPA notice: No consent is given for interception of page transmission.